If you are starting a newsletter, or thinking about moving one, Beehiiv and Substack are two names you will meet early. Both let writers publish to email and the web, and both support paid subscriptions. The difference is mostly in approach: Beehiiv positions itself as a toolkit for running a newsletter as a business, with growth, advertising and analytics features built in, while Substack is widely known as a simple place for writers to publish and charge readers directly. This article compares the two honestly. Our directory holds a full listing for Beehiiv, so its details are specific; we do not hold a data file for Substack, so we describe it only in general, well-known terms and avoid claims about its pricing or features that we cannot verify.
Beehiiv vs Substack at a glance
| Aspect | Beehiiv | Substack |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Newsletter publishing platform | Newsletter publishing platform |
| Paid subscriptions | Yes | Yes |
| Hosted website and archive | Yes | Not covered in our data |
| Drag-and-drop editor | Yes | Not covered in our data |
| Audience segmentation | Yes | Not covered in our data |
| A/B testing | Yes | Not covered in our data |
| Automation workflows | Partial | Not covered in our data |
| API access | Yes | Not covered in our data |
| Free plan | Yes, with a subscriber limit | Not covered in our data |
| Pricing model | Freemium | Not covered in our data |
The "not covered" cells do not mean Substack lacks those features. They mean we have not verified them, and we would rather leave a cell open than guess.
What Beehiiv offers
Beehiiv is a newsletter publishing platform launched in 2021 by former staff of a well-known media newsletter company. It is designed for writers and media brands who treat a newsletter as a business, combining email sending with a hosted website, a post archive and tools for growing and earning from an audience.
Writing and publishing
Publishers write in a block-based editor, send to audience segments and publish each issue on a web page that can be found through search. That web archive matters for long-term growth, because each issue can keep attracting readers after the send. Custom domains are available, along with landing pages and an API for connecting other tools.
Growth tools
Growth is where Beehiiv puts much of its effort. It includes referral programs, recommendations between newsletters, polls, surveys and a subscriber analytics dashboard. A/B testing is listed as available, which helps writers test subject lines or content choices rather than guessing.
Monetisation
Beehiiv supports paid subscriptions, a built-in advertising network that matches advertisers with publishers, and digital products. Some earnings features, such as the ad network, may come with eligibility conditions, so our editor recommends checking the eligibility rules for advertising and paid tiers early, since they affect how soon earnings can begin.
Automation and plans
Automations handle welcome emails and simple journeys; our data marks automation workflows as partial rather than full, so do not expect the depth of a dedicated marketing automation suite. A free plan supports a limited number of subscribers, and paid plans add unlimited sends, more advanced automation, custom domains and increased referral and monetisation tools.
Where Beehiiv is weaker
Beehiiv focuses on publishing rather than e-commerce or sales funnels, and e-commerce integration is only partial, so online stores will find fewer product-based features. It also has fewer general marketing tools than larger suites, and the free plan carries restrictions. It runs on the web only in our listing.
What Substack offers
Substack is a well-known newsletter platform where writers publish posts to email subscribers and can offer paid subscriptions to readers. It is widely associated with independent writers and journalists who want a straightforward way to start writing and to charge readers directly for their work.
Because we do not hold a verified listing for Substack, we are not stating its prices, fees, subscriber figures or detailed feature list here. If those details decide your choice, read Substack's own current terms and pricing before committing, and compare them with the Beehiiv plan details on its listing page.
Key differences to think about
- Business toolkit versus simplicity. Beehiiv bundles referrals, recommendations, polls, surveys, segmentation, A/B testing and an ad network. Substack is generally seen as a simpler writing-and-subscription platform.
- Monetisation routes. Both support paid subscriptions. Beehiiv adds an advertising network and digital products, with eligibility conditions on some features.
- Brand and domain. Beehiiv offers custom domains on paid plans and a searchable web archive, which suits writers who want their newsletter to feel like their own media brand.
- Integrations. Beehiiv provides an API and integrations. We have not verified Substack's integration options.
- Verification. Our comparison is stronger on Beehiiv because we hold its data. Treat the Substack side as a starting point for your own research.
Questions to ask before you choose
- How will you earn? If paid subscriptions alone are the plan, both platforms are candidates. If you also want sponsorship income through an ad network, Beehiiv's built-in network is worth a look, after checking eligibility.
- How will you grow? If referral programs and cross-newsletter recommendations are central to your plan, Beehiiv lists them as core features.
- How much do you want to manage? More features mean more settings. Writers who simply want to write may value a lighter setup.
- Will you sell products? Neither platform should be your first choice for an online store; Beehiiv's e-commerce integration is partial, and our data does not cover Substack's.
- Can you leave later? Check how each platform lets you export subscribers and content before you build a large list.
Migrating an existing newsletter
If you already publish somewhere else, moving is mostly about your subscriber list, your archive and your paying readers. Before switching to Beehiiv, list what you need to bring across, confirm how your current platform exports subscribers and posts, and plan how paid subscribers will be moved without disruption. Test a few sends to a small segment first, check that your custom domain and web archive look right, and only then announce the move to your full audience. The same checklist applies in reverse if you ever decide to leave.
Which should you pick?
Choose Beehiiv if you see your newsletter as a media business and want growth tools, segmentation, A/B testing, analytics, a searchable web archive, a custom domain and several monetisation routes in one place. It is a strong fit for independent journalists, analysts and niche publishers with ambitions to build an audience, provided the eligibility rules on monetisation features suit you.
Consider Substack if you mainly want a familiar, straightforward place to write and offer paid subscriptions, and you are comfortable verifying its current terms yourself.
If neither fits, compare more options in our Beehiiv alternatives list or the wider email marketing category, which includes creator-focused and self-hosted newsletter tools.
FAQ
Does Beehiiv have a free plan?
Yes. Beehiiv's free plan supports a limited number of subscribers. Paid plans add unlimited sends, more advanced automation, custom domains and extra referral and monetisation tools.
Can I charge readers on both Beehiiv and Substack?
Yes. Both platforms support paid subscriptions. Beehiiv also offers an advertising network and digital products, with eligibility conditions on some earnings features.
Is Beehiiv good for online stores?
Not especially. Beehiiv focuses on publishing, and our data lists its e-commerce integration as partial, so stores will find fewer product-based features.
Why does this comparison have fewer details about Substack?
We only publish facts we can verify from our directory data. We do not currently hold a Substack listing, so we describe it in general terms and recommend checking its current pricing and features directly.